Reading Response 10: NOCSUS Chapter 10, Incite! Chapter 13, Incite! Chapter 15

In our last class, we spent a portion of our discussion focused on the question of the future of nonprofits. This conversation arose from the current relationship between philanthrocapitalists and nonprofits and the potential ways Donald Trump’s administration will influence the future of nonprofits. A possible outcome presented was one wherein those who nonprofits support (e.g. immigrants, LGBTQ+ community, people in poverty) would experience further oppression under Trump’s administration and simultaneously a loss of the resources from nonprofits receiving less governmental help that would potentially push these groups into an even direr situation.

In NOCSUS chapter 10, a look at the future of nonprofits is discussed, although not with the same lens of our class discussion. According to the authors “the nonprofit sector is not static, but constantly evolving and ever-changing” (316). This chapter appears to be describing a reciprocal relationship between changes or “trends” in society and nonprofit organizations, as both will influence each other. Six different changes are discussed as pertinent to the future of nonprofits, which are “demographic shifts, fiscal stress and uncertainty in government spending, increased demands for transparency and accountability, market competition and pressures for performance, blending and blurring of sector boundaries, rise of technology and social media” (316).

The growth of the “majority-minority” divide, aging of the population, and increasing poverty in suburban areas are pointed out as key demographic shifts in the coming years. To respond to these changes, the authors suggest “greater diversity within the nonprofit workforce and among nonprofit leaders and boards” (319), working with those who are retired but “not ready to leave the workforce” (322), providing “more services to the elderly and aging communities” (322), recognizing a potential increase for demand on goods and services needed by those living in poverty, and recognizing the challenges of access to nonprofit services in suburban areas (325).

The discussion moves from service-oriented changes and goals to a focus on the potential challenges government will create for nonprofits in the future. The authors describe how the issue of “uncertainty of government spending” is not just a future problem but a current one as “government decision-making with regard to spending and other budget matters has grown increasingly unpredictable due to economic decline and efforts to limit the role of government” (325). In order to deal with a future of “reduced donations and increased local tax payments” and the effect of the government’s challenge of “meeting the competing needs of various political parties” and “balancing the federal budget,” the authors describe how nonprofits are currently turning towards fundraising, earned income, and several other sources of funding to deal with this uncertainty (327). For the future importance of transparency and accountability, the authors appear to be suggesting vigilance on the part of nonprofits to “manage oversight” and monitor “their own activities” as the public has a high level of confidence in nonprofits (328).

In “Market Competition and Pressures for Performance,” the authors describe a new issue of an increase in the “net loss of the number of nonprofit organizations in some area” that has arisen from market saturation and competition for resources (334). The suggestion offered by the authors in dealing with this issue is for anyone planning on starting a nonprofit organization to conduct a “thorough market analysis” to see if their organization would be viable (336). The two sections on the “blending and blurring of section boundaries” and “rise of technology and media” focus on how nonprofits are changing internally to achieve their goals. According to the authors, “any nonprofit scholars and practitioners would argue that nonprofits are becoming increasingly business-like, treating clients like customers, adopting more profit-driven activities, hiring more employees and leaders with business backgrounds, and in some cases changing their status from nonprofit to for-profit, limited-liability corporations” (337). This movement to becoming more “business-like” is shaped by the view of those being served by nonprofits moreso as “customers” and the introduction of more earned income. Several goals are being achieved through social media as “organizations who employ these new technologies to fulfill a variety of goals including fundraising, cause marketing, volunteer and staff recruitment, policy advocacy, and political change efforts” (339).

While this NOCSUS chapter doesn’t convey a negative or pessimistic view of the future of nonprofits, the chapter does end on an interesting note of how “despite these challenges, we can find reassurance in the fact that the nonprofit sector has shown great resilience throughout its short history, embracing new opportunities and adapting to environmental pressures and changes like no other sector” (344). While the authors emphasize the “resilience” of nonprofits, I think this chapter also points to nonprofits as malleable or adaptive. The authors appear optimistic that nonprofits will be able to adapt to the upcoming changes and thrive in the changing world. For me, the idea of nonprofits as malleable, adaptive, and resilient connected to the texts “Radical Social Change: Searching for a New Foundation” and “Non-profits and the autonomous grassroots.”

The “Radical Social Change” text can be described as showing the inability of nonprofits to adapt. The author recounts her work with Sista II Sista and the effect becoming a 501(c)(3) had on the group. She relates the struggles of her organization once it was government funded to the struggles of mass movements today. In response to the question of “where are the mass movements of today within this country?” the author claims “they got funded” (186). Once movements and organizations aiming for social justice are “incorporated into the non-profit model,” they are “limited” (186). The main component of this limitation for the author appears to be the movements turn from focusing on “struggle and growth at every level” to “pimping our communities’ poverty in proposals, selling ‘results’ in reports and accounting for our finances in financial reviews” (191; 187). To address this issue, the author looks to movements in countries outside of the United States, which have “the least access to foundation funding,” but yet have been able “to do the most in terms of developing mass-based movements for radical social change” (185).

“Non-profits and The Autonomous Grassroots” appears to be taking a somewhat different take on nonprofits than “Radical Social Change.” Eric Tang appears to see value in both grassroots organizations and the viability of nonprofits. Tang’s text focuses on the movement from several radical groups to becoming or being incorporated into a nonprofit in the 1980s, which is described by the author as “self-identified revolutionary forces within this New Left turn[ing] their attention to party-building efforts aimed at consolidating the many movements in order to strike a unified revolutionary blow against the establishment” and “many activists on the Left began to insist that in order to have impact, the movement needed to take on the sharper image” (218;219).

While the author focuses on the negative outcomes of this shift toward the beginning of the text and especially the thoughts and feelings on part of a new generation of activists towards this shift, Tang emphasizes the value of nonprofits in relation to the failures of grassroots organizations in the past. Tang claims “burn-out” was an issue with prior movements that brought along participation in nonprofit organizations. “Burn-out” refers “not only to those who failed to pace themselves and in the end ran out of gas, but also to those who, during their days in various revolutionary parties and collectives, were burned by internal political processes and buses of institutional authority” (220). In a sense, nonprofit organizations appeared to be offering a “safer” space for certain members of movements to continue to do work related to a movement, while “being able to survive” (220). Tang claims that ultimately the inability of radical movements to “care for the long-term development and health of all its members” and “to promote a movement culture wherein folks from many walks of life could contribute in a variety of ways” is what “led to the sweeping NP phenomena we’re seeing today” (220-221).

I think all three of these texts read consecutively leave readers with the question of what is the better route to help those in need and/or facing oppression? Are grassroots organizations and mass-based movements the best route? Are nonprofits the best method or are a combination of all three forms the best method? With the three texts combined there’s a great discussion of the negatives and positives of each route and I think the clearest conclusion on the most “successful” route for change that I can currently come to is to use the goal to determine the method. Both texts from Incite! have the goal of mass movements that lead to change as their outcome and therefore follow a line of thinking which each author determines will best lead to this end. This NOCSUS chapter appears to have the goal of addressing the immediate needs of others and therefore sees nonprofits, with their resilience and adaptability, as the best approach to deal with the immediate challenges of society.

Reading Response 9: Guest Speaker, Emily Martin

To coincide with our discussion of philanthrocapitalism, Emily Martin, a Transylvania University alumna and former student of the first iteration of this course, was our guest speaker. While our discussion with Martin did not focus on philanthrocapitalism, we did have a fruitful discussion about certain experiences in Martin’s current graduate career that were applicable to this course and beyond this course. One of the big takeaways from this discussion was the value of asking questions when creating texts for and to used by someone other than yourself.

Martin described one of her early experiences in philanthropy of having to write a letter to have a course funded. While she saw the value in the course, she didn’t, at least, initially find any connection between asking for funding for a course and how she envisioned philanthropic work. For her, this dissonance led to a struggle with creating a text, which was not only felt by her, but also her boss as her words didn’t communicate the enthusiasm or passion he had previously noticed from her. In response to this situation, Martin decided to task herself with finding out more information about the course and the benefits of the course for its students and what her boss found most enjoyable about the course. Getting insight into a professional and personal perspective on these courses appeared to have at least given Martin more material to accomplish her task and potentially assuaged her feelings of dissonance.

While asking further questions may sound like a simple task or solution, I think Martin’s insight not only about asking questions, but about how at times, even in a field which you’re interested and passionate about, you’ll encounter assignments or tasks that don’t connect to with you and/or leave you discontent, connects well with our group project. As a group, I think we’ve definitely experienced some of the feelings Martin may have felt with her previously mentioned assignment. From our discussions of the project, it appears as though we all saw the value of creating a video about poverty for the Community Action Council and had some interest in tackling the subject, especially the stigmas surrounding poverty. I think the act of visually representing the differences between youth living in poverty and youth not living in poverty is one of the most obvious feelings of dissonance or disconnect that we’ve often discussed and pointed to with this project. Ultimately, this issue has been dealt with, but I think in several stages of the project this dissonance created a loss of passion and a level of hesitancy, that at least for me, made the project feel slightly dire or as having the potential to become an inaccurate and problematic representation of youth in poverty.

Throughout this process, I think asking questions of the CAC has helped us to an extent. With our initial letter to the CAC, in which we were asking for their vision of the video, we were able to further understand that we would be focusing on a certain CAC project and not just “youth in poverty in Lexington,” which likely reduced some fear or concern about the direction of the project. I also think the questions later about pinpointing the exact audience or goal of the video also has strengthened our development of the project. While this may be stretching the idea of asking further questions presented by Martin, I think that our group’s experience with the response of the participants in the Project LIFE program to our questions has personally done something similar to Martin’s experience with asking further questions about the courses she was asking to be funded.

The responses from the three participants of the Project LIFE program has not only given us valuable insights for our final video project, but has also, for me, brought me to a greater understanding of the program’s goals, the way this program has helped certain individuals, and the way representatives of the CAC have helped with this process (the interviewees mentioned consistently how long and supportive Cynae, a representative for the CAC, has been during their time working with CAC). I think having these answers, rather than just the information on the CAC’s page about what Project LIFE is and does has added an even greater sense of value to the project.

As mentioned by Martin, we’ve all experienced projects or assignments where we really can’t engage with the assignment in a positive or fruitful way. I think our struggle with figuring out our feelings towards our CAC project is valuable as it presents a long-term experience with this sense of dissonance, versus a short-term engagement where one might have to write a brief paper for a course where they’re unable to engage. With a long-term experience along these lines, I think Martin’s advice becomes more valuable as one can’t “push through” a semester-long video project in the same way one can “push through” and complete a brief writing assignment they may lack interest in. The long-term experience definitely requires more negotiation with oneself and others. Through Martin’s experience, it’s clear this feeling of dissonance can happen and likely will happen in one’s post-undergraduate life and therefore the value of curiosity presented by Martin and the value of having the ability to feel comfortable voicing concerns about a task with oneself and others and using this discussion as a positive avenue to deal with the discontent, lack of passion, or dissonance is a “beyond the course” takeaway.

Response 8: Bishop and Green’s Philanthrocapitalism: How Giving Can Save the World and Ramdas’ “Philanthrocapitalism: Reflections on Politics and Policy Making”

Matthew Bishop and Michael Green open their preface for Philanthrocapitalism: How Giving Can Save the World with a news report on a meeting of the “super rich.” For Bishop and Green the importance of this meeting of the “super rich” is tied to the context and goal of the meeting. This “secret gathering of billionaires” was occurring post the 2008 financial crisis and the goal of these billionaires “was for the leaders of philanthrocapitalism to share what they had learned about how to be effective givers, and to brainstorm about philanthropy should meet the new challenges posed by the economic meltdown that had begun the previous year” (ix). According to Bishop and Green, “philanthrocapitalism” is a movement “focused on tackling the world’s toughest problems through effective giving” and is also a way to describe the usage of business techniques by philanthrocapitalists for philanthropy (x). “Philanthrocapitalism” is also described by Bishop and Green as related to the “leaders of capitalism” realizing that within the capitalist system “giving back” is as important as earning money (x).

Bishop and Green’s first chapter “The Age of Philanthrocapitalism” focuses more in-depth on philanthrocapitalists and their aims, views on philanthropy, and influence on giving. Warren Buffett and Bill Gates are used as the examples or exemplars of philanthrocapitalism. Bishop and Green claim Buffett and Gates as “leading a revival and reinvention of old tradition that has the potential to solve many of the biggest problems facing humanity today” (2). This “old tradition” is philanthropy and the “reinvention” Bishop and Green refer to is the application of business methods to this “old tradition” to “equip” philanthropy “to tackle the new set of problems facing today’s changing world” (2). Part of this method includes “thinking big and going for it,” being “social investors,” finding betters ways to work with nonprofits, and focusing on “the profit motive to achieve social good” (6).

The act of philanthrocapitalists “thinking big” can be seen in their aims to eradicate diseases and/or poverty from “poor countries.” By being “social investors,” philanthrocapitalists aim to support those “who offer innovative solutions to society’s problems” (6). Post-2008 financial crisis, nonprofits likely need the help of philanthrocapitalists more than before and Bishop and Green describe the potential role of philanthrocapitalists in this realm as mediators between “governments, businesses, charitable NGOs, and philanthropists” (12). According to Bishop and Green, philanthrocapitalism’s emphasis on profit is controversial as the question of “isn’t philanthropy supposed to be giving away money, not making more of it?” arises (6). Bishop and Green showcase Wal-Mart and Google’s use of “profit motive to achieve social good” as a positive outcome of philanthrocapitalism’s influence, but also state “the test of these fine words will be whether rich philanthropists and companies can walk the walk as well as they talk the talk” (7). The chapter ends by emphasizing philanthrocapitalists as “hyperagents” as they have the “capacity to do some essential things far better than anyone else” (12). According to Bishop and Green, philanthrocapitalists “do not face elections every few years,” do not “suffer the tyranny of shareholder demands,” and do not “have to devote vast amounts of time and resources to raising money” (12). For Bishop and Green, philanthrocapitalists not having to deal with these previously mentioned barriers can potentially bring something new to philanthropy as philanthrocapitalists are able “to think long-term, to go against conventional wisdom, to take up ideas too risky for government,” and “to deploy substantial resource quickly when the situation demands it” (12).

In their preface Bishop and Green claim “tough questions should be asked about whether the wealth was created legitimately, whether a reasonable amount of taxes have been paid on it and whether the giving is done in a thoughtful way designed to make a genuine difference” (xi). While along with this Bishop and Green emphasize how if philanthrocapitalists “can walk the walk as well as they talk the talk” as a potential issue with philanthrocapitalism, Bishop and Green’s lack of interaction with potential criticisms of philanthrocapitalism (at least in the preface and first chapter) can potentially leave a reader with a lot of questions and/or concerns about the potential negative aspects of philanthrocapitalism (7). For example, Bishop and Green focus on how philanthrocapitalists “have the capacity to do some essential things far better than anyone else” through their ability to avoid certain barriers (12). On the surface this discussion in their text sounds promising, especially for the act of giving, but the fact that billionaires are not beholden to certain systems and have substantial resources in comparison to some nonprofit organizations is a potential problem and factor in the existence of some societal ills these billionaires are trying to alleviate.

Philanthrocapitalism can create a lot of tension as the valuable work and potential valuable work these philanthrocapitalists are doing for society exists alongside how the position these philanthrocapitalists are in and capitalism potentially play a role in creating or furthering certain social issues. With Kavita N. Ramdas’ text “Philanthrocapitalism: Reflections on Politics and Policy Making,” the tensions arising from Bishop and Green’s discussion of philanthrocapitalism are explored. Ramdas’ concern is that “far too few in this elite club are willing to ask themselves hard questions about a model of economic growth that has made their phenomenal acquisition of wealth possible in a nation where over 800 million people still languish in poverty” and “despite many good intentions,” philanthrocapitalism “seems poorly suited to resolve the world’s most deep-rooted problems” (393;394). According to Ramdas, philanthrocapitalism does not address issues at a systemic level, especially as it avoids philanthrocapitalists examining and rectifying their role in systemic issues.

Ramdas’ texts and the issues that arise from Bishop and Green’s text are very reminiscent of our in-class discussion generally about how nonprofits or anyone seeking to help those “in need” do or not address the systemic nature of societal issues. We’ve mostly discussed the importance of understanding issues at a systemic level through our focus on poverty with texts like “Portrait of Poverty,” “Accompaniment as Policy,” and A Framework for Understanding Poverty and our discussions with the Community Action Council. Ramdas’ text also connects well to The Revolution Will Be Not Funded, which also briefly mentioned in Ramdas’ text, and NOSCUS Chapter 8. Both of these texts focus on the role of nonprofit organizations in dealing with systemic issues and being a part of social movements.

In NOSCUS Chapter 8, a view by some people on nonprofit organizations as potentially useful by acting as an “organiz[ing] and mobilizing vehicle for coalescing interests and effectively engaging the political process to demand social change,” but also as “inhibitors” of “true social change” by “watering down the radical elements of more spontaneous mass movements” is presented (258). Through Bishop and Green’s and Ramdas’ text presentation of philanthrocapitalism, philanthrocapitalists can potentially be described in a similar way to the previous description of nonprofits. While philanthrocapitalism organizes and encourages wealthy givers, along with everyday people, towards philanthropy, the existence of philanthrocapitalists and philanthrocapitalism is heavily tied to capitalism and therefore tied to the systemic issues, which philanthrocapitalists are attempting to address. This connection has several benefits as seen through the positive outcomes of philanthrocapitalism in Bishop and Green’s text, but in the long-run has a potential “inhibiting” effect on addressing social issues as philanthrocapitalists are not addressing the underlying issues that perpetuate social issues through their giving and their business model of giving.

Progress Report 3

Since the conference on my working draft/outline, I have been working on developing my analysis section and on structuring my introduction section. Prior to my conference, I was struggling the most with these two sections. In my conference, the discussion about how to potentially use my idea for incorporating another source’s analysis of George W. Bush’s rhetoric in response to 9/11 as a parallel to Trump’s rhetoric and as a way to focus on the potential outcomes of Trump’s style of rhetoric has led to me not only rethinking my introduction, but also to rethinking how I plan on discussing the implications of Trump’s rhetoric. In terms of my introduction, realizing that I don’t have to justify the choice to focus on the rhetoric of politicians in general through a discussion of Bush has decreased some confusion about what I need to discuss in my introduction.

Bush’s rhetoric has also reminded me that no matter who wins the upcoming election, Trump’s rhetoric doesn’t just disappear and therefore positioning his rhetoric within the context of similar styles of rhetoric or aims of rhetoric will help to predict potential ways, in which his rhetoric could become vital or foundational to the rhetoric of his supporters. As I complete this project I will not be so distanced from the moment that this speech happened and Trump’s overall presidential campaign to analyze this rhetoric through “hindsight” and therefore having this sort of predicative capability will be important to discussing the implications of Trump’s rhetoric.

With the analysis section of the fantasy-theme criticism of Trump’s speech, I was struggling with how to organize potential components of the analysis and what I planned on focusing on within Trump’s speech. Currently, I have decided to focus on the three characters Trump emphasizes throughout his speech: Americans, Hillary Clinton, and immigrants from the “Middle East.” While the settings of Trump’s speech are important, constructing a rhetorical vision or an understanding of Trump’s rhetorical visions by focusing on setting themes seems as though it would be messy especially as two of these characters (Americans and Clinton) exist within this setting, along with Trump as a character. Emphasizing the setting could weaken the analysis by not allowing me the room to explain the importance of these characters for Trump’s rhetorical visions. Trump ascribes many different actions to the characters of Americans, Hillary Clinton, and immigrants from the “Middle East” and therefore analyzing Trump’s rhetorical vision through the lens of character themes seems like the best way to create an accurate and understandable picture of the importance of these actions within Trump’s rhetorical visions.

As of right now my current argument is along the lines of “Trump uses the Orlando Nightclub shooting to encourage policy against immigration from the “Middle East” and place himself as the person to “carry out” this policy (Trump as hero) by positioning Americans as ideal/good citizens who need to be concerned about what they can and should do to stop this “kind of immigration” into the country and how their prior support of immigration policies/lack of stance against immigration policies has played a role in several current tragedies (essentially, responsibility of these ideal/good citizens to the nation) and by positioning Hillary Clinton and immigrants from the “Middle East” as the main sources of the United States issues, which these ideal/good citizens should be aware of and should want to get rid of.”

The feedback from Thursday was also helpful in moving my project forward. The response to my artifact summary led me to thinking about how I envisioned my incorporation of Trump’s speech throughout my analysis. The summary was pretty lengthy, since it covered basically everything in Trump’s speech. I plan on keeping this summary for future reference, but ultimately aim to shorten the summary in my actual paper. When I re-read through the summary, I realized my biggest goal was to summarize the entire speech for myself so as the researcher I could feel confident about my knowledge of the speech. I definitely think I accomplished this task with my artifact summary, but I’ve also realized my audience doesn’t necessarily need this lengthy summary, especially as I aim on incorporating a lot of direct quotations from Trump’s speech into my analysis portion.

The feedback also helped with the question of how should I deal with any inconsistency or incoherence in Trump’s speech. During the working draft/outline conference, we discussed ways to determine if coherency was even important to Trump’s audience and this was definitely helpful in terms of moving me away from my concern that I was just overall misunderstanding Trump and for thinking of potential ways to incorporate this discussion, if needed, into my paper. In the group feedback to this previously mentioned question, I really appreciated the response that I should just “embrace” the lack of unity Trump may present and that I should not try to avoid discussing this component and its potential effect on Trump’s audience.

Response 7: NOCSUS Chapter 8

This chapter of NOCSUS aims to discuss how those who fit into categories like lacking voting rights, resources, and belonging to marginalized groups “engage in the political process and bring change to their communities” (248; 251). Social movements or individuals “com[ing] together to advocate for some large-scale social reform” are pinpointed as the way or method for marginalized individuals to participate in the political process and change society (251). Throughout this chapter, the authors discuss the relationship between nonprofit organizations and social movements and several theories as to how social movements come to be. These ideas are then applied by the authors to past, contemporary, and contemporary international social movements to assess the role of nonprofit organizations in this context and to assess how potential theories behind social movements explain these movements.

A main component or foundation the authors use as a reason for social movements is “when the government or society is not responsive to [citizens] needs and interests” and therefore citizens typically aim “to force large-scale change through disruptive political and social actions such as protests, marches, and civil disobedience” (252). To explain further what causes social movements than just the lack of government and societal response to needs of citizens, the authors discuss several theories of social movements derived from sociology and political science. One theory discussed is the “classical model,” wherein “strains” in the political, economic or social spheres leads to social movements. Other theories mentioned in this chapter focus on social movements as a highly collective act or an act influenced greatly by “individual discontent” (254). Social movements are also viewed through the lens of resources, wherein “resource deficiencies” leads to individuals pooling resources or resource abundance or improved resources for members of marginalized groups leads to the ability of these individuals to help form social movements. A final theory or lens for social movements points to the elite as potential motivators for social movements by “provid[ing] social movements with the resources needed to achieve their goals” (255).

According to the authors there is a degree of “disagreement” around the role of nonprofit organizations in social movements (257). Nonprofit organizations are described as potentially useful by acting as an “organiz[ing] and mobilizing vehicle for coalescing interests and effectively engaging the political process to demand social change,” but also as “inhibitors” of “true social change” by “watering down the radical elements of more spontaneous mass movements” (258). In contrast to both of these arguments, some researchers view the formation of a social movement into a nonprofit organization as the outcome of “truly effective mass movements” (258). Ultimately the authors appear to take an overall positive view of the relationship between social movements and nonprofit organizations as they conclude the chapter by highlighting the previously mentioned ability of nonprofit organizations to organize, mobilize, and once social movements are formalized into nonprofit organizations, the ability of these organizations to “continue to advance the social justice, equality, and other missions and goals of the movement” (276).

While the potential relationship between social movements and nonprofit organizations came up with our reading of The Revolution Will Not Be Funded, I had not specifically connected social movements and nonprofit organizations in any way outside of the idea of nonprofits as being potentially being harmful to social movements. In NOCSUS, potential benefits from nonprofit organizations to social movements and examples of past benefits and relationships between nonprofit organizations and social movements have complicated my understanding of nonprofit organizations and mass societal change, which was influenced by The Revolution Will Not Be Funded. Nonprofit organizations as a space for material and nonmaterial resources to coalesce and gather “like-minded” individuals was focused on in a past chapter of NOCSUS, but applying these resources to large-scale social movements rather than just a nonprofit organization’s local community is a different avenue for nonprofit organizations to support members of society.

The change of a social movement into a nonprofit organization was also, for me, a previously unthought of idea of how some nonprofit organizations potentially were created. Much like nonprofit organizations supporting social movements, the creation of a nonprofit organization from a social movement also has the potential benefits and hindrances for social movements. As mentioned in NOCSUS, a social movement formed into a nonprofit organization can have a positive outcome by continuing to sustain specific goals of a social movement. Nonprofit organizations typically rely somewhat on government funding and donors with members of the “elite” having the ability to donate the most. As the goal of social movements and therefore the goal of a social movement formalized into a nonprofit organization typically relates to “shaking up” structures and relationships of power in society, a nonprofit organization that is funded by the government or elites could face difficulty with receiving help from these areas if they are aiming to disrupt the power of these groups.

In this chapter, the authors also mention social movements as “unpopular in the mainstream US” and that “most Americans never participate in protest movements” (253). This information led me to reflect on the speakers in-class from nonprofit organizations, which focus on alleviating social issues, and the relationships between these organizations and social movements. From what I remember, many of the speakers did not describe their interest in working for/with their current nonprofit organization as derived from their role in social movements or the existence of the nonprofit organization as derived from specific social movements. I have begun to wonder how do nonprofit organizations view social movements that are related to social issues the nonprofit is trying to alleviate? How does the lack of involvement in social movements by members of a nonprofit organization potentially influence the type of actions the nonprofit takes to alleviate social issues and the actions the nonprofit does not choose to take to alleviate social issues? For example, does a nonprofit “shy-away” from tactics or methods associated with social movements?

Response 6: Dan Portnoy’s The Non-Profit Narrative

Within the seven chapters of Dan Portnoy’s The Non-Profit Narrative: How Telling Stories Can Change The World, he focuses on how non-profit organizations can use a “multi-channel approach” and “the metaphor of a Three-Act story structure” to present the organization’s message and story (2). The first chapter of Portnoy’s text positions the member of a non-profit organization using this text as a “screenwriter” (6). According to Portnoy, storytelling, when done well enough, can be one of the best ways to impact an audience as stories are incredibly important for humanity and serve multiple purposes for humans from “making sense of the world” to discussing ideals and behavior (5). This first chapter mostly focuses on the concept of the “Hero’s Journey” (8). The discussion of the “Hero’s Journey” or a “central character on a quest” sets-u Portnoy’s “essential elements of your story” discussed in chapter two (8; 24).

A key component of both a “Hero’s Journey” and Portnoy’s essential elements are the protagonist and antagonist. Portnoy describes a non-profit as having a “multi-protagonist story,” which means both the non-profit organization itself and the people who work for the organization are the protagonist (26). The antagonist of a non-profit organization is the answer to questions such as “what’s the issue that you’re fighting?” (27). Portnoy’s essential elements also consist of the setting or “physical location of the drama,” the “inciting incident,” which for a non-profit organization would be the answer to “why was your organization started?,” and tension that can be used during a “crisis moment” (25; 31; 33).

The major component of how Portnoy idealizes storytelling for non-profit organizations is focused on the three acts of beginning/set-up, middle/conflict, and end/resolution. While applying Portnoy’s three acts to a narrative presented in a movie is likely easily understandable, Portnoy takes this traditional format and applies it to non-profit organizations in an interesting way. Portnoy’s act one, two, and three are connected to campaign one, two, and three for an organization. Before an organization’s campaign begins, Portnoy suggests the organization starts with introducing materials, which present the “why” and the antagonist of the organization’s story around January.

Portnoy suggest the climax in act one (February-April) and act two (May-August) focus on the organization’s events. After this, August-September is suggested as time to focus on acquisition, while act three (October-December) or the largest campaign is focused on making sure that “your organization is functioning on all cylinders, donors are connecting with you the most, that they have the tools they need to help convey your message and that they’re telling the best possible story” (47). According to Portnoy, the third act is crucial as this timeframe is typically when most of an organization’s donations are going to happen.

Chapter four, five, and six emphasize the audience’s potential response to an organization’s representation, especially through digital spaces. Portnoy claims the first step to engaging with one’s audience is to “define” the audience and learn everything about them, then figure out the specific behavior you want your audience to accomplish, and then figure out the systems or how you will be communicating with your audience to encourage the defined behavior. When thinking of how to promote and design for an organization’s target audience, Portney also emphasizes the “continuum of communication” or “pathway of engagement” as a method to use when communicating with audiences.

In this method, members of an organization’s audience can move from “observer to participant to owner” (67). This happens as members of the audience moves from watching by looking at the organization’s website or advertisements, to engaging by liking on facebook or signing up for emails, to the act of being an owner by having an investment in the organization that can be described as being as “much on board as they can with your organization as they can be without having a job there” (70). The final chapter of Portnoy’s text appears to act as the last push or final motivation for Portnoy’s readers to take his advice and apply the advice to their organization.

Portnoy’s text reminded me of a component of this course which is listening to speakers from non-profit organizations. While a portion of Portnoy’s text focuses on digital media and storytelling, potentially any act wherein a representative of a non-profit organization is discussing the organization can be seen as a chance for using storytelling to enhance or provide further insight and interest into a non-profit organization. Prior to this text, I did not really think much about the storytelling being done by several of our speaker’s as a way to gain or sustain an audience in the ways Portnoy mentions, but rather as just a tool to establish context or background for an audience.

The Nest’s Executive Director Jeffrey White stands out for me when thinking of non-profit organizations and storytelling in the context of Portnoy. For the discussion on the overall existence of The Nest and for the discussions about The Nest’s programs, White heavily focused on the “why” or “inciting incidents” for The Nest as much as what exactly the organization does. White incorporated stories about himself and The Nest, other workers and volunteers and The Nest, and people who were using The Nest’s services heavily in his presentation. These stories, especially the one’s about those using The Nest’s services, all had a protagonist and an antagonist.

White also did something reminiscent of the act one, two, and three mentioned by Portnoy when he discussed The Nest’s major events throughout the year and how these events related to funding the Nest received. I think as an audience, White’s discussion or storytelling also left us with something we could “pass on” as Portnoy describes when discussing how well-done stories tend to make those interacting or encountering an organization have an emotional reaction to the organization. When the audience reacts in an emotional way to the storytelling, they might want to do something with or for the organization, potentially by volunteering, donating, or telling the organization’s stories through different avenues like everyday conversation or digital spaces.

Response 5: Shut Up and Shoot Excerpts

The excerpts from Anthony Q. Artis’ Shut Up and Shoot focus mostly on the technical aspects and planning involved in filming and ultimately creating a documentary. A portion of the first excerpt focuses on preproduction or planning the important components of a film like topic, theme, interviews, locations and the equipment and crew needed to accomplish the major goal of effective storytelling. As a member of the group creating a video for the CAC about youth in poverty, the preproduction section contained valuable insights that will help with any potential struggles we may have and to create a video that potentially accomplishes Albert Maysles idea of using the documentary (or in this case short realistic/depiction of youth in poverty) to “know one another” and “to know what’s really going on in the world around us” (6).

In “Brainstorming Your Idea,” Artis encourages viewing what films or books on one’s chosen topic already exists and think about the approach used by the creators to discuss the chosen topic (7). In our meeting with representatives from the CAC, we sort of discussed the potential approach to the material and goal of showcasing a realistic view of the lives of youth in poverty. A serious, but light-hearted tone for the video was the idea conveyed to our group and the ASPCA commercials with Sarah McLachlan was identified by the CAC representatives as the major example of what the video shouldn’t look like.

While our group has thought about the obvious cheesy or problematic representations of youth in poverty or poverty in general that we’re aware of, we haven’t really discussed positive, well-done, or accurate visual representations of poverty. I think our texts used for this course have showcased positive, well-done, and accurate approaches to discussing poverty and these texts have currently been guiding our group’s thought process on appropriate questions to ask the interviewees for this video, but as we move forward looking at visual approaches to discussing or showcasing poverty, which we agree are well-done, will likely help generate further ideas for the video.

The discussion on types of documentaries in the first excerpt from Shut Up and Shoot also appears to be somewhat applicable to our video project (12). Artis pinpoints expository, observational, participatory, and dramatic as four different approaches to storytelling in a documentary. From the meeting with the CAC representatives and our own group’s different discussions it appears as though our video project, while not exactly a documentary, is aiming to present youth in poverty in a more “expository” way, as we’re attempting to persuade our target audience to get involved with the CAC and to inform this audience about the reality of poverty and we’ve been discussing the idea of potentially “using images to support the words” (12) of our interviewees.

One thing we’ve been struggling with are the approaches classified by Artis as a part of a “dramatic” approach. This approach primarily consists of having reenactments of events. The CAC representatives discussed contrasting the stereotypical or idealized version of youth with events like prom, high school graduation, and acceptance into college with how youth in poverty live. In order to accomplish creating this contrast, we would likely have to use not necessarily reenactments for the idealized version of youth, but actors. In showing how youth in poverty live, we’ve discussed our dilemma with doing reenactments, using actors, or getting consent from actual youth in poverty with each other and also in class. While we’re still working through figuring out how to best deal with these previously mentioned ideas, I think Artis’ insight into using other films as examples and thinking further about the relationship between the goal of the video and the act of storytelling will help in dealing with this issue.

The second half of the first excerpt and the second excerpt focus more on the actual act of filming. Although we won’t be working with filming equipment with a lot of the same capabilities as mentioned in Artis’ text, a lot of the knowledge about the act of filming is still valuable to our project. Deciding when to use a tripod or when to go handheld, recording protocol, audio, location, and appropriate titles might seem obvious, but sometimes these components of filming get “lost” or forgotten as the group focuses on other aspects of the video project like what exactly we’re going to film, who we’re interviewing, and how to piece clips together. In the “Visual Language of Docs” section in the second excerpt, the discussion of the usages of establishing shots, wide shots, medium shots, and close up will likely be important to our video project as these elements play a role in “visual storytelling” and how filmers approach the subject of their documentaries.

Response 4: A Framework for Understanding Poverty

A Framework for Understanding Poverty is the outcome of Dr. Ruby K. Payne’s experiences as an educator and from her realization that “there were major differences between generational poverty and middle class–and that the biggest differences were not about money” (2). Payne claims poverty is caused by “interrelated factors” and that working definition of poverty focuses on seven resources (financial, emotional, mental, spiritual, physical, support systems, relationships/role models, and knowledge of hidden rules) and “the extent to which an individual does without [these] resources” (3;5). In order to illustrate the importance of these different resources in one’s ability to stay in or leave poverty, Payne uses seven scenarios, wherein she places the reader in the role of head of the household and gives a checklist of resources for the reader to think about within the context of each scenario. The scenarios come from “cases” with which Payne has “become acquainted” (9).

Another excerpt from Payne’s book touches on the role of relationships for students in poverty and how making “emotional deposits” and respect towards the students are key components to developing successful relationships and that any organization, specifically schools, should create relationships “by promoting student achievement, by being role models, by insisting upon successful behaviors for school” (111). The final excerpt focuses on the “additive model,” which is placed in contrast to the deficit model that  “names the problems and blames the individual” (170). This model appears to be aimed at usage by schools and focuses on creating an accurate mental model of poverty, studying poverty research, naming problems and finding solutions, hidden rules of economic class, language uses, family structures, sharing knowledge, and knowledge and community sustainability. The role of the additive model is to help “understand and address poverty and the underlying factors that have perpetuated it” (183).

Payne’s text relates well to the different ideas present in the poverty simulation this weekend. Her seven resources gradually appeared as important factors as we worked our way through the hour long simulation. I think from the very beginning the financial resource as a factor in poverty was obvious and therefore the resource most of the family I was in focused their attention towards. The group that I was a part of attempted to tackle this issue first, by having the employed grandparent go to work and making sure the employed grandparent’s check was cashed and therefore useful to pay for the rent and utilities.

One element of Payne’s list of resources that became apparent to many of us as we worked through our tasks was support systems. Payne defines support systems as “having friends, family, and backup resources available to access in times of need” (7). Many of the employed members of different families began to rely on each other to share transportation to work and to understand the roles of the available resources around the room. In the family I was a part of, one other resource became apparent, but we did not necessarily attempt or were able to attempt to address the issues related to these resources. The grandfather in this family was disabled and had diabetes, which relates to the physical resource in Payne’s definition of poverty. The grandfather’s physical issue made him unable to earn income and also increased the medical expenses of the family and ultimately, these two aspects made this family’s ability to thrive and leave poverty even more difficult.

Between Payne’s text and the poverty simulation, the difficulty of leaving poverty or even the ease in which one could slip further into poverty was emphasized. These factors related to the seven resources within the simulation and within Payne’s scenarios, all played an influential role  in the simulation families as the lack of these resources caused the families to become impoverished or caused the families in poverty to further stay in poverty, all played an influential role in the situations of these families. Both Payne’s text and the simulation also give insight into how difficult gaining and sustaining these resources are and how simply knowing these resources exist or do not exist in a family is not the end of understanding the situation of someone who is in poverty.

While in the simulation we became aware that we were lacking time or input into the relationship aspect of the resources, we were unable to accomplish incorporating this into our lives as we ended up placing the financial aspect above everything else and did not have time to implement or even contemplate the role of relationships within our family. To an extent, the family we were portraying had little choice when it came to fulfilling certain resources and little external help to fulfill these resources. For me, through participating in this simulation and viewing the simulation through the lens of Payne’s texts it has become further apparent to me the role and importance of nonprofits like the Community Action Council, wherein organizations like this one can help families in poverty fulfill these resources, but also potentially create an environment for families to even have the time or choice to think about the resources Payne mentions.

Response 3: Grant Writing as a “Means to an End”

This excerpt from Joseph Barbato and Danielle Furlich’s Writing For A Good Cause deals with, to an extent, what these two authors deem as an assumption “that pervades most fund-raising offices” (14). This assumption is that “anyone can write” (14). In order to explain their issue with this assumption, Barbato and Furlich discuss what could be described as the writing process or writing experience of those working within the context of fundraising offices. Barbato and Furlich claim those under this previously mentioned assumption treat writing the same way they do any activity, such as breathing or walking, which they approach with little thought (14), write mostly for an audience that either appreciates or cares about their writing, or view writing as a “necessary evil” for fund raising (15). The approach Barbato and Furlich suggest to those writing for fundraising purposes to use to move away from this assumption is to take the act of writing and the writing itself as seriously as the fund raiser would hope a funder takes their proposal (15). The authors aim to help fund raisers  do this by showing “how to use words well to win the support of funders” (17).

In the chapter “Today’s Development Office: Who Does What and Why,” Barbato and Furlich create a fake fund-raising or development office to give a general overview of the roles and relationships of the fund raiser-in-chief, the researcher, the major gift officers, the director of development, the volunteers and others, and the writer. In this short description, the writer’s work is described as “produc[ing] the written materials needed to raise funds” and also writing and editing proposals, concept papers, case statements, articles and newsletters, brochures, web sites, letters, and presentations (37). While the role of editor and writer in this section is vague, Barbato and Furlich provide further insight with the chapter “The Role of the Writer: Using Words for a Cause.” This sections emphasizes the flexibility of a fund raising writer, as they have to typically “respond to demands” (49) of those they are working for, in terms of generally creating a text, genre of the text, the longevity of the text (letter vs building inscription), and the quality of other coworkers texts.

Although Barbato and Furlich describe the role of the writer as hinged on the needs of their coworkers, the underlying theme or job of a fund raising writer is “to sell the organization” (47). This idea of “selling” the organization ties in well with and harkens back to an idea mentioned at the end of chapter two, which is “as we shall see, this [fund raisers having to play it by ear] places special pressures on the writer, who must flourish amid ambiguities and whose words are never in and of themselves the end product but always an important means to an end–raising money for the cause” (44). To me this idea from Barbato and Furlich and the previously mentioned idea of “selling” the organization pointed to the idea that while the writing for fundraising should be taken seriously and not approached with the negative or lackadaisical method mentioned by Barbato and Furlich, when crafting these texts that are supposed to “lure” funders with words, the emphasis of the writer should be on creating these well written texts to serve the organization’s goals.

This idea of words or writing as a “means to an end” reminded me of the “How Do I Know If I Need a Grant?” section in lesson 2 of The Only Grant Writing Book You’ll Ever Need. The main piece of advice given in this section is to figure out if your organization needs a grant, “you must have a problem that you (and/or your organization) want to solve, decide what you need to do to solve it, and figure out how much that might cost” (12). Ellen Karsh and Arlen Sue Fox’s response essentially suggests that an organization should have a well-planned out and well-designed program that requires additional funding, rather than creating a program in response to the existence of a grant. Thinking of this previously mentioned idea alongside my takeaway of “means to an end” has me positioning Karsh and Fox’s advice as also suggesting an organization should write for grants as a “means to an end,” rather than just to write or respond to grants to “chase” funding. In a roundabout way, this notion of “means to an end” helped me further understand the importance of nonprofit organizations being “mission driven” (12).

The act of writing the grant and potentially obtaining the grant should be seen as a way to accomplish the goals of a program that aligns with a nonprofit organization’s mission. This previous statement is likely incredibly obvious but ultimately this idea of mission driven versus grant driven caused me to reflect on ideas discussed by some of the speakers and the class’s connotations of nonprofits discussed on the first day. In terms of speakers, this idea of “means to end” brought to my mind the speaker, who formerly worked for North Limestone Community Development Corporation. When asked to explain the process of starting a nonprofit organization, he briefly went through steps along the lines of finding something you care about, seeing if someone is already dealing with the subject you care about, and finding funding. These steps relay the idea of forming a nonprofit organization around needs and concerns first, rather than forming an organization around what receives the most funding and this act of need and goals before potential funds connects to writing and grants as a “means to an end” and being mission driven, rather than than grant driven. This idea of being mission driven is also interesting as it provides a way to explain to outsiders the goals of the organization, but also can keep those within the organization in “check” or “on task,” when it comes developing programs, partnerships, or applying for grants.

In terms of the class’s connotations, this idea of mission driven organizations presented me with a potential factor to our positive connotations of nonprofits. Through ideas presented in Karsh and Fox’s text, nonprofits that serve their communities well and are offered support by funders are those that are mission driven and aim to be consistent with their goals and this act of staying aligned with a mission potentially builds the credibility and positive connotations of these organizations, not only for their funders, but for students like us or anyone that may not be involved in nonprofit organizations in positions other than volunteer.  

Questions/Topics of Discussion for Second Reader and Outside Reader

As I’ve been looking further at my chosen artifact of Donald Trump’s speech in response to the Orlando Nightclub Shooting and have developed a greater understanding of fantasy-theme criticism, several questions have arisen. These new questions, along with questions that have arisen since I’ve begun thinking about the discussions and questions presented in my prospectus conference, are all potential questions that I want to address with my second reader and outside reader.

One of these questions, which is likely obvious, but still important is: What are sources or ideas from your field/area of study that could complement my chosen topic and help make sense of Trump’s rhetoric?

While I’m using an artifact that is in response to a specific tragedy, the ideas, themes, and rhetoric presented in this speech don’t “exist in a vacuum” and Trump’s rhetoric and ideas in the past likely influence this particular speech and the response of his audience to this speech. My current understanding of using fantasy-theme criticism in an attempt to understand a “shared reality” or “shared worldview” of groups points to this analysis as taking the themes in this speech of Trump’s and creating an understanding of the larger rhetoric and ideas of Trump and Trump’s audience, but how much of Trump’s rhetoric prior to this speech should I incorporate to create a foundation for this analysis or to further support the analysis I develop from fantasy-theme criticism? How much do I need to look to the past outside of Trump’s rhetoric and ideas, in terms of past representations of the topics which this tragedy hits on for Trump (immigration, Muslims, LGBTQ+ community) to ground or contextualize the presentations of these topics in Trump’s speech?

I’m also particularly worried about fatigue or “burn out” of my potential audience around the subject of Trump. While the presidential race and the topic of “weaponized” grief are important, with the current saturation of discussion around Trump in mind, what are potential ways that I can frame this project/discussion that will engage my audience who may be “burned out” by discussing Trump?

There’s been a lot of discussion around media analysis or engagement with Trump and whether or not this engagement or analysis has been approached in the most ethical way and/or has failed to challenge issues with Trump. Are there any ethical issues I should be concerned about when analyzing Trump and presenting my findings from this analysis?

I’m currently envisioning the audience response or the response of surrogates to Trump’s speech as a key component to my analysis. What are potential approaches I can use to determine which supporters of Trump I will be looking at? When making this decision, what are potential criteria for the responses I choose to incorporate into my analysis?

In Trump’s version of his speech on his website and in the transcript/video of the actual speech Trump gave, there is the inconsistency of Trump describing Omar Mateen as born in Afghan in his live speech and as born to Afghan parents who immigrated to the United States in the version of his speech on his site. How should I deal with this inconsistency or any other inconsistencies that come up? Is this difference important at all?

My final question focuses on what to do with the fact that Trump’s speech was “given” or presented live. While fantasy-theme criticism focuses on analysis of texts or language, should elements of Trump’s visual presentation of his speech inform my work in any way? Would this be pertinent or just extra material that could draw me away from my topic and research goals?